"Atlas medicine: Prof. Martin Lambeck as a tail gunner in Esowatch? denounces Prof. Martin Lambeck recently private intimate enemies under cover of anonymity? This impression, at least one article that the illegal Internet portal Esowatch (1) recently about the so-called medical Atlas published by the Berlin physician Dr. Ing Herbert Koerner (here's a screenshot (2) the online magazine psychophysik.com). The language in the style of the Berlin physicist articles written widely in addition to true and demonstrably false information. The presentation is generally biased and misleading. They conceal important facts embarrassing for Professor Martin Lambeck . 
IMPORTANT: Please note the note at the end of this blog comment. GWUP.WATCH recently reported in detail on the Internet portal
Esowatch (3) . The list of critical issues listed there has just been supplemented by a further point:
7th Targeted illusion "Esowatch authors are like snipers, the people from the anonymity out sneaky attack, without (false) to take responsibility for their statements. An example: The Esowatch article "Atlas medicine" was written almost certainly the active participation of Prof. Dr. Martin Lambeck (4) . Esowatch conceals important here for Lambeck very embarrassing information in the (deliberately cited) Article "pseudo-science at times to know: The" healer can test "by Prof. Martin Lambeck ..." be found. The statement on Esowatch-Pils glass experiment is a deliberate misrepresentation. The experiment has worked in the presence of Lambeck was, however, he misinterpreted. "
targeted by disinformation Esowatch aim of this commentary is not to write a plea in favor of Dr. Herbert Koerner and all its atlasmedizin.de on the website to support
popular theories. Mr. Koerner is a colorful character and his ideas about manual medicine, biological cybernetics, bionics, neurophysiology, psychology and quantum mechanics are worth to be critically scrutinized. If however, a known critic Koerner try to spread under cover of anonymity kicks below the belt, then the Berlin physician a right to fairness and correction. The Esowatch article about the so-called medicine of Mr. Atlas Koerner teeming with tendentious, misleading and false representations. This comment is limited to four major issues: first
The beer glass experiment worked Esowatch writes about the so-called beer glass experiment
(5) by Dr. Herbert Koerner:
"When involved in a demonstration of Körnersche pilsner glass effect, the physicist and well-known skeptic Martin Lambeck was, and this was experimentally set up the beer glasses on two separate tables were, - as expected from classical physics ago -. show the rotational effects are no longer " This statement is incorrect. truth is, however, that that experiment worked in Anwesentheit Mr Lambourne. Lambeck former interpretation of the successful experiment ("coupled oscillation") is wrong and embarrassing for a physics professor, because the beer glasses were swimming in water. "Coupled Oscillation" is a rigid medium, requires the transmission of vibration. The magazine writes on page 83 times to know its issue No. 4 / 2006 also
"added Martin Lambeck the glasses left no moment in the eyes. 'Da' he shouts, 'it is moved,' "The exclamation Lambeck documents the functioning beer glass experiment.
x 
x 
x 
x second The beer glass puzzle is still unsolved Esowatch writes in regard to the beer glass puzzle:
"This is the 17th Century by Christiaan Huygens announced that clocks can share good in a common wall with classical physics inexplicable way (pull-in effect or lock-in effect) low mechanical energy, to be synchronized after a while lead coupled oscillations. " This statement man is a Freudian slip. Why is a speculative Explanation necessary if the experiment in the presence of Lambeck has reportedly not working yet? The speculation is necessary because the experiment worked in reality and was by Dr. Herbert Koerner evident in the way several times before successful research institutions. It is true that to date no serious scientific explanation for the phenomenon is. An outstanding scientific investigation might conclude that the hypotheses are supported or refuted by Koerner and Lambeck. The
of Esowatch (conspiracy on the Internet) and Prof. Martin Lambeck (publicly in Berlin) as a speculative statement called lock-in effect
(6) can not be the explanation of the pilsner glass phenomenon for several reasons: a) weakly coupled oscillation requires a rigid medium for the transmission of vibrations. As the beer glasses are like buoys in the water swimming, lack this medium. b) do not commute, the rhythmic pilsner glasses but turn around its own axis. c) The unexplained rotation of the second did not affect beer glass is extremely slow (to the eye almost invisible) after a delay of 5 to 10 minutes, if that's according to Prof. Martin Lambeck and Esowatch allegedly catalysing manually rotated glass already come to a standstill.
Prof. Martin Lambeck and Esowatch show the lock-in effect-a typical argument for so-called dogmatic skeptics behavior. To answer a dubious them occurring explanatory myth by their own dubious explanatory myth. This interesting behavior is also documented Wikipedia users FOSSA
(7) and the Heidelberg sociologist Edgar Wunder
(8). third Lambeck writes dubious healer test Esowatch:
"Atlas Medical is the name of a medicine with no alternative humankybernetischen became known efficacy of the Berlin orthopedic surgeons, engineers and spiritual healer Herbert Koerner. The method can, in the broadest sense as an esoteric-inspired method of chiropractic or manual Medicine are understood. This was indeed in medicine no notable response and reception led, however, at least to a report by RTL TV and Article in VDI news of the Association of German Engineers, as well as in The world and Berliner Morgenpost . Serious to be named literature or technical articles in recognized journals are referred to the Atlas medicine is not in scientific databases " correction. First of all, Koerner no
spirit healer represents and himself not as
spirit healer dar. The wording
spiritual healer Esowatch was probably chosen to give the article a defamatory and derogatory ductus. Esowatch known not pursued the goal of informing neutral and objective. Intention of the authors, it is instead to fight from their subjective point of view worthy of criticism and active people to brand publicly.
The presentation fails to mention that Dr. Herbert Koerner has for years been actively but unsuccessfully about finding a scientific institution, which explores his therapeutic approach. Prof. Martin Lambeck Koerner had raised against the impression that he would his treatment during his
"hard tests for gentle healer" (9) Check serious. As it turned out, possessed Prof. Martin Lambeck and his club GWUP
but neither the methodological and scientific medical knowledge nor adequate resources to a crucial question to beanworten serious:
Is "Dr. Herbert Koerner and his method in the able to free people from pain? " This issue could be with your selected Lambeck means (no pre-coordinated and scientific meet minimum standards experimental design
(10) , but a fun weekend meeting in the Berlin villa grains) not serious answer.
The following
Esowatch Notice is against this background not only wrong but also cocky:
"Some witnesses before screenings and tests carried out on 21 April 2006, no major from Koerner postulated therapeutic effects that went beyond a possible anticipated placebo effect. " The study conducted by Lambeck alleged" healer test was "in the scientific sense, frivolous, totally useless to any reliable statements about . come As mentioned here Esowatch conceals important Lambeck embarrassing information in the article
"pseudo-science at times to know: The" healer "test Prof. Martin Lambeck ... " can be found.
principle applies: "The lack of evidence for an effect is not the evidence of absence of an effect" (Altman DG, Bland JM: Absence of evidence is
not evidence of absence BMJ 1995; 311th (7003): 485). The guest
Atlas Medical useful as
or
not recommended can be made only after a scientific study. The lack of scientific literature cited by Esowatch allowed neither positive nor negative statements. The strange "healer" test Prof. Martin Lambeck may however be classified as a curiosity with pseudo-scientific nature.
4th Misleading to Koerner's reception in scientific circles: For the reasons mentioned above can be found by Dr. Ing Herbert Koerner no publications in scientific literature databases such as PubMed. Koerner is a practitioner who has discovered and developed a therapeutic method and that in practice such as the care of high-performance swimmers (Berlin) applies. For the conduct of clinical trials, which are subsequently to publish in scientific journals and to provide professional public discussion would be missing him but the possibilities. The same holds true for Prof. Martin Lambeck, of its "critical work" towards alternative medicine (with good reason!) Is not published in scientific journals.
EsoWatch The wording of the article gives the (presumably desired) false impression that Koerner would find work in the medical community no reception.
This impression has a defamatory character, and is wrong. in the prestigious journal published
Praxis H. Koerner and A. Würzner 2010, Article
"small pulse - big impact" . Views one has the
Advisory Council orthopedic practice to, this professional magazine certainly a greater reputation than the
SKEPTIX mentioned club Journal of Lambeck-Vererins GWUP eV Herbert Koerner is also regularly called upon by medical experts to present a therapeutic concept at conferences . He gave lectures on the ICCMO-(International College of Cranio-Mandibular Orthopedics) Winter Meeting in Würzburg (2008), at the German Congress of Orthopaedics and Trauma Surgery in Berlin (2008) or on the 57th and 58 Annual Meeting of the Association of South German orthopedist e. V. in Baden-Baden (2009, 2010).
No question, provoke arguments Koerner and his therapeutic work. Herbert Koerner has however earned, fair and serious questions to be reviewed and. The article is in character with EsoWatch.com a
insulting criticism . And so it's no surprise that run against the publishers EsoWatch
Klaus Ramstöck since end of June 2010 government investigation.
Prof. Martin Lambeck as a tail gunner in Esowatch? summarize that characterized the linguistic articles by the signature of Prof. Martin Lambeck will contain important information that any Esowatch authors Unknown - Prof. Martin Lambeck, however, known - are. Esowatch-author Deceptor
(11) has the Atlas Medicine article definitely only put on the web and not even written. Spoke thus considerable evidence for the proposition that Prof. Martin Lambeck strikes by conduct which is not worthy of a serious scientist. The challenged person Dr. Herbert Koerner was no chance to participate in the presentation and will continue to attack by a sneaky sniper who under cover of anonymity is not responsible for his (false) statements.
way: Even GWUP.WATCH his comments circulated anonymously and without Legal Notice. However, this is a direct response to the unethical behavior of Esowatch. GWUP.WATCH immediately receives a legal notice as soon reveal the publisher and the authors of Esowatch their identity and address.
IMPORTANT NOTE: This blog comment is an opinion again, is not to be understood as an assertion of fact. Several clues lead us from the perspective of GWUP.WATCH to believe that Prof. Martin Lambeck Esowatch author of the article "Atlas medicine" or the writing of this Article, at least a considerable contribution. Evidence for this assumption GWUP.WATCH are not available. . GWUP Association About the Association: ass Watch:
wiki entry "GWUP" .
